


No 4 (2024)
Special Theme of the Issue: Anthropology of Affective Atmospheres
On Atmospheric Turn in Social Sciences
Abstract
The article introduces a special theme of the issue on the “Anthropology of Affective Atmospheres”, featuring contributions by S.V. Sokolovskiy, D.A. Radchenko, S. Runkel, and an interview with T. Griffero. Readers of this thematic issue are acquainted with the new area of philosophical and social research, which until now has practically not attracted the attention of Russian anthropologists, despite the fact that the so-called “atmospheric turn” has deeply influenced quite a wide range of social sciences and humanities, including anthropology. The main goal of this issue of the journal is to familiarize Russian anthropologists and ethnologists with theoretical and methodological foundations of (affective) atmospheres research and specific case studies in this field. The main task of this introduction to the topic is to review relevant concepts, to recommend the most influential publications, the familiarity with which is expected to facilitate the introduction of these subjects into field ethnography programs, and to provide a brief overview of the current “atmospheric” research in the country.



In Search of Atmospheres: Directions, Methods, Perspectives (an Interview with Tonino Griffero)
Abstract
The article is a commented translation from English and German of an interview, conducted in February 2024 with the Italian philosopher-phenomenologist, professor of aesthetics at the University of Rome “Tor Vergata”, the current undisputed leader in the study of (affective) atmospheres Tonino Griffero. The interview touches upon a diversity of traditions in atmospheric research (including national variation in such studies), the correlation of the notions of atmosphere with the notions of mood (Stimmung) and ambiance, research methods and ways of theorizing of atmospheric phenomena by German phenomenologist Hermann Schmitz (16.05.1928–05.05.2021) and aesthetics specialist Gernot Böhme (03.01.1937–20.01.2022), and, finally, the prospects of employing the relevant methods and approaches in social sciences, including anthropology.



Touching the City: Tactility and Affect of Public Art
Abstract
Touching objects of public art is one of the most frequently recorded and at the same time superficially described practices of interaction with the urban environment. I propose to look at this practice through the lens of the “affective atmospheres” approach, which allows us to problematize tactile contact as a means and result of affective attunement with space. Analyzing the affective-discursive canon, emerging around the interaction with a new art object (the sculpture “Big Clay No. 4” in Moscow), I demonstrate how, on the one hand, the transition from digital to visual and tactile interaction with the materiality of space creates collective affect online; on the other hand, how this affect is transmitted to social media, making the public art object the center of a phygital hybrid space.



Religious Inflection in the Economy of Experience: The Concept of Atmosphere in Aesthetic and Phenomenological Thought of Hermann Schmitz and Gernot Böhme
Abstract
The article offers a brief genealogy of the concept of atmosphere in the thought of Hermann Schmitz (New Phenomenology) and Gernot Böhme (Aesthetic Theory) to show that the concept takes on a quasi-religious appearance, especially in its design and economic applications. It is shown how a phenomenological concept of religious origin could become a pseudo-psychological marketing strategy. The article argues that the concept of atmosphere should not be applied too exclusively to the design of (interior) spaces, but that the sociality of atmospheres should also be taken into account. In this way, attention can be drawn to the manipulative power of the atmospheric.



Biological Anthropology
The Origin and Affinities of the Tagar People: A View from Half a Century Later
Abstract
To revise the origins and external relationships of the Tagar population (800–300 BC) nearly half a century after my book (1977), 36 male Tagar cranial samples were compared with 117 samples representing other periods and regions using multivariate statistical methods. To date, the principal contenders for the role of Tagar ancestors are the Andronovans, whose key role is supported by genetic facts. The pre-Andronovo substratum was likely represented by the Chaa-Khol’ people of Tuva and the Yelunino people of the Upper Ob. The Karasuk tribes do not appear to have taken part in Tagar origins. Among the neighbors of the Tagar people, the closest to them are the Pazyryk people of the Ursul, Altai, and certain Sagly people of Aimyrlyg, Tuva. Judging by the dates, those groups resulted from a southward migration of certain Tagar populations at the Saragash stage. Since the Chaa-Khol’ people, as I showed previously, were extremely close to Scythians of the steppes, and among the Tagar people, to those of the Saragash stage, it appears that the Saragash people or their descendants had migrated not merely to the Altai-Sayan region but also much further west – to the Eastern European steppes. The archaic Scythian culture, which preceded this migration, may have spread along the same route, but by way of diffusion.



The Ciboney and the Taino in the Context of Craniometric Variation in Native American Population
Abstract
The article examines two cranial samples representing the pre-Columbian population of Cuba (the Ciboney and the Taino), in the general context of craniometric variation in the indigenous population of the American continent. Published craniometric data from various sources were used for comparison by the canonical discriminant analysis and calculation of pairwise squared Mahalanobis distances. The question is raised about the possibility of including artificially deformed crania (of which the Taino and many other American samples are entirely composed) in the analyses using only the metrics of the facial skeleton. When analyzing samples without artificial deformation, similarities were found between the Ciboney and South American groups, mainly from the West, which may indicate their origin from an ancient and less differentiated type that inhabited Central and northwestern South America in ancient times. The results of the analysis combining deformed and non-deformed samples are more difficult to interpret, which may indicate a significant influence of cranial vault deformation on the morphology of the facial skeleton, but they do not contradict the conclusions of studies of related sciences about the South American origin of the Taino.



Research Articles
Spatial Modeling of the Folk Astronomical Knowledge among the Residents of Tajikistan
Abstract
The term “folk astronomical knowledge” refers to a set of practical knowledge that allows a person to navigate in space and time. An important point is the possibility of a total assessment of this knowledge not only at the level of an individual, but also at the level of a separate settlement or region. The authors developed a method for determining an indicator characterizing the level of folk astronomical knowledge, based on field materials collected in the Republic of Tajikistan in 2019–2023. The method was verified on a large sample (177 people were surveyed). The average values of the “coefficient of knowledge” (k) made it possible to assess the process of knowledge loss among informants of four age groups, as well as to compile maps reflecting the preservation of folk astronomical knowledge in the studied territories. The analysis of the maps makes it possible to propose a model describing the observed prevalence of this knowledge. Its maximum level is recorded along the Pamir Tract, in the zone of active information exchange, and the minimum is in isolated valleys. Based on the proposed model, high-quality predictions were made about the level of popular astronomical knowledge in areas that have not yet been surveyed.



Religious Identity in the Context of Present-Day Ritual Culture of the Kyrgyz People
Abstract
The article examines the ethnographic aspects of the religious identity of the Kyrgyz people, expressed through attitudes to the rituals of the family cycle, mainly funeral and memorial rites. The article describes the features of the development of religious culture, regional differences in the manifestation of religious identity, the place of ritual in the discourse between traditionalism and Islamic normativity, and issues of regulating rituals. The uniqueness of the history of the religious life of the Kyrgyz people is noted, which lies in repeated modernization during the 20th century: the transition from total atheization to the revival of religious consciousness. The diversity and inconsistency of religious identities, the nature of the clash of positions between different trends on the values of the folk ritual of the family cycle are studied. It defines that today the rituals of the folk have become the central issue of the discourse between traditionalists, Islamic normativists, “statists” and representatives of secular approaches. The author comes to the conclusion that the regulation of some aspects of rituals, in particular funeral and memorial rituals, shows a tendency towards convergence of state and religious (Islamic) approaches, which in the future may lead to contradictions between different identities.



Modern Cinderellas: The Specifics of Marriage Strategies for Women with Disabilities
Abstract
The article examines life strategies of disabled women who wish to find a spouse/life partner and build a family. We take the cases of contemporary Russia and Kazakhstan as countries that in many aspects share a common post-Soviet social and cultural background. Israel, which is considered one of the countries favorable for disabled people, is additionally taken as a case for comparison, for in fact there live many impaired ex-Soviets including women with disabilities. Drawing on own field research, we attempt to outline the principal models of marital behavior of such women in the countries under examination, pinpointing their specificities in each case. We argue that despite different social and cultural surroundings as well as varying ethnic and religious traditions, the factor of double stigmatization – both of disability and of gender stigmatization – makes a profound impact on self-identifications of these women who feel more vulnerable if compared with so-called “normal” women.



Images of Industrial Cities of Tatarstan in the Vision of the Leaders of Urban Communities and Ordinary Residents
Abstract
The article examines the verbally recorded dominants of the vision and construction of images of non-capital industrial cities of Tatarstan by their leading actors, accepted and described in their own way by ordinary citizens. They are supplemented by the author’s personal observations and analysis of the meanings embedded in urban symbols and toponymy, monumental propaganda and works of art. Conducted in 2021–2022 in Naberezhnye Chelny, Nizhnekamsk, Almetyevsk, and Zelenodolsk, expert interviews and problem-oriented interviews with families showed that their industrial specialization (and, accordingly, the designation as a city of mechanical engineers, chemists, oil workers, shipbuilders), as well as the associated features of the mentality of the residents, continued to determine their images. Moreover, the plant becomes a kind of invisible “partner” for every city dweller, setting the rhythm and style of life, key moments of historical memory. At the same time, the individuality of settlements is influenced by the peculiarities of the formation of their population, sociocultural spaces and urban culture, including ethnocultural specifics.



Cultural Traditions of the Motu through the Prism of Centuries: Life between Two Worlds (New Guinea)
Abstract
The Motu Melanesians have since ancient times played a significant role in the economic life of many Papuan and Melanesian societies in the coastal regions of the southeast of the New Guinea island. From the late nineteenth century onward, Motu villages experienced considerable influence of colonial administrations. Subsequently, following Papua New Guinea’s independence in 1975, the impact of globalization intensified, causing significant cultural transformation. To date, however, the Motu continue to maintain their strong cultural identity.



Book Reviews and Critiques
The “Imaginative Horizons” of Vincent Crapanzano [“Gorizonty voobrazheni voobrazheniia” Vinsenta Krapanzano]



The World of Chiri Yukie’s Deities [Mir bozhestv Tiri Yukie]: A Review of Pesni bogov naroda ainu, zapisannye Tiri Yukie [Ainu Divine Songs Collection Compiled by Chiri Yukie]



A Book That Stood the Test of Time [Kniga, proverennaia vremenem]: A Review of Evenki v sovetskii period (iz neopublikovannykh rabot) [Evenkis in the Soviet Period (from Unpublished Works)], by G.M. Vasilevich


